← Back to the short version

The details

The full reasoning behind the Tubkins page: what is on the shelf, the five hard parts, what the bar is made of, the money, and the build plan.

The shelf today

The market, and what is already on the shelf.

Estimates for the wider baby personal care market run from $7 billion to $96 billion, depending on the research firm and what it counts. I am using the narrower bath number above and leaving the flattering one alone.

As for the bars that do exist, I read the labels. Johnson's still sells one, but it is traditional true soap made from tallow, and true soap runs alkaline, around pH 9 to 10, well above the skin's own pH. Dr. Bronner's baby bar is castile, which is also true soap. Baby Dove, Cetaphil, and Sebamed Baby all sell a genuinely mild bar built on gentle synthetic cleansers, and Sebamed already prints pH 5.5 on its label. Aveeno Baby, a Kenvue brand like Johnson's, has added a soap-free cleansing bar marketed for newborns and "co-created with pediatricians and dermatologists." It is built on sodium cocoyl isethionate, designed to a pH of 5.0 to 6.0, and it adds fragrance, which Tubkins leaves out. Mustela sells a soap-free, fragrance-free shampoo and body bar in a plastic-free carton for $12.50, labeled for ages three and up, with a 94 percent natural origin figure on the box.

So mildness is not the open ground, and I am not going to pretend it is. What none of these has is a character; every one is a plain bar. The gentle bar already exists. The one a child asks for by name does not.

The hard parts

Five real problems, and my answer to each.

01

Our mild formula is not proven yet

True soap runs at pH 9 to 10, too harsh for a baby, so the bar has to be a syndet: a mild synthetic cleanser set near skin pH. Baby Dove and Aveeno Baby already sell syndet bars for infants, so a mild baby bar is proven. Ours adds one open question. Both of theirs are built on isethionate, which the main natural certifications do not accept, and we are building on sodium cocoyl glutamate instead. Glutamate is used mostly in liquid cleansers, and we found no published record of it in an extruded, stamped bar at scale.

My answer

The first call to Twincraft in Vermont and Vanguard in Memphis asks one thing: can you extrude and stamp a glutamate-led bar, and does it hold up in a wet tub? It will likely need a binder system of fatty alcohols and stearic acid. Both run bar lines at scale and keep large libraries of dies, and neither publishes glutamate bar experience. If the answer is no, the fallback is an off-the-shelf syndet base from Stephenson, which runs on isethionate or, in its certified grades, sodium coco-sulfate, and a smaller natural story.

02

Parents bathe a baby with one hand

Most baby wash comes in a pump for a reason: one hand holds the baby and the other does everything else. A slippery bar is a fair objection.

My answer

Make the bar easy to grip when wet and sized for a parent's palm. Expect the strongest use in the toddler years, when children start helping in the bath and asking for a favorite; Mustela already labels its bar for ages three and up. In the newborn months, Tubkins is a gentle second cleanser alongside the wash parents already trust.

03

Small children put everything in their mouths

A small, colorful, friendly object near a toddler is a fair thing to worry about, and it is the first question a retailer's safety reviewer will ask. Soap also shrinks, so a bar that is big when new gets small eventually.

My answer

Never embed a toy; a hidden toy is the obvious choking risk. Make the new bar much larger than the federal small-parts test cylinder, a toy standard we adopt voluntarily, and test how small a worn bar gets before it breaks apart. The carton tells parents to retire the bar once it gets small. Keep the form a single rounded solid with nothing that snaps off, keep the formula low-irritant, and settle preservation with the manufacturer, since contamination drives many soap recalls. A friendly shape is not a toy, and it should not pretend to be one.

04

Faces are expensive to make and wear off

Fully sculpted three-dimensional characters are cast in molds, slowly and at a high cost per unit. A simpler stamped face is cheap to make, but it softens as the bar is used.

My answer

The hero bar is a rounded shape with the face stamped in as a relief, which runs on standard extrusion and stamping lines; most drugstore bars are made the same way. The wet-tub test tracks how many baths the face stays readable, and the depth of the eyes and smile is set to last. A fading smile can double as the cue that it is time for a new friend. Fully sculpted characters wait for limited-edition drops, where the price covers the slower process.

05

A big brand could do this next week

This is the one that worries me most. Unilever already owns both halves of this idea. It makes Baby Dove, a mild synthetic bar for infants, at scale today, and in September 2025 it closed the $1.5 billion purchase of Dr. Squatch, which bought it the personality-brand playbook. Kenvue, which owns Johnson's and Aveeno and is being bought by Kimberly-Clark, has just added a soap-free Aveeno Baby bar, so a second giant already makes the bar we would put a face on. A realistic copy would be a smiling embossed bar in the Baby Dove line at about three dollars.

My answer

Accept that the formula is not defensible, and stop pitching it as though it were. What we can own is narrower than it sounds: our characters, their names once cleared, the artwork, and the trademark. Those let us act against a copy of Tubkins. They do not stop Unilever from pressing a different smiling face into a bar. So the real protection is speed and affection: file the trademark application now, register the copyright in the character art, get a patent lawyer's view on a design patent for the bar shape, and take the registry and specialty shelf while a company that size is still deciding whether a nine dollar novelty is worth a line review. If the honest outcome is that one of them would rather buy this than build it, that is one of the exits this plan is built for.

What it is made of

Mild first, natural where we can, and honest about the difference.

"Syndet" is short for synthetic detergent. We chose a syndet because it is the mildest bar format we found, so this bar will not be one hundred percent natural, and we will not say it is.

The usual mild cleanser in these bars, sodium cocoyl isethionate, cannot earn the main natural-cosmetics certifications, COSMOS and Ecocert, because one of its building blocks is made from ethylene oxide. So we build on sodium cocoyl glutamate instead: made from coconut oil and sugar, certifiable, and very mild. Whether it can carry a bar is hard part number one above.

ComponentWhat it does
Sodium cocoyl glutamatePrimary cleanser, COSMOS certifiable
Sodium cocoyl glycinate, coco-glucosideFoam and lather, each grade confirmed as certifiable
Shea butter, sunflower oil, vitamin ESoftening oils, plus an antioxidant so they stay fresh
Vegetable stearic acid, cetyl alcohol, kaolin clayHardness and binding, so it holds together in a wet tub
Citric acidBrings the bar to skin pH
Ultramarines, iron oxides, chromium greenMineral colors from FDA's approved list, mineral by our choice
No fragrance at allLeft out on purpose

The colorant trap, which nobody warns you about

Because our bar is a syndet and not true soap, FDA treats it as a cosmetic (it would be a drug only if we made drug claims, which we will not), and a cosmetic like ours may use only color additives FDA has approved for cosmetics. Botanical colors like spirulina and beetroot are not on that list. A true soap that makes only cleansing claims falls outside those rules, which is why some soapmakers can use them and we cannot. The approved list still has real options, including synthetic dyes and a few plant colors such as annatto and beta-carotene, but we are choosing mineral pigments because they are stable and fit a certifiable formula.

What that costs us

Blue and pink come from ultramarines. Minty needs a chromium or ultramarine green and will read softer than the render. Sunny was the hard one: a mineral yellow is ochre, not lemon, so Sunny is now a honey ochre, and every image on this page shows that shade. If a plant yellow such as beta-carotene holds its color through stability testing, it is the one exception we would consider.

One more catch. Ultramarine pigments break down in acid, fading and giving off a sulfur smell, and a fragrance-free bar has nothing to hide that. So we specify an acid-resistant coated grade, consider a target nearer pH 6, and prove color and odor hold through accelerated stability before any tooling. If they do not hold, Tubkins moves to ferric ferrocyanide, a blue on the same FDA list, and Poppy moves to a diluted red iron oxide.

We will not say "one hundred percent natural"

The FTC has declined to define the word, so there is no safe harbor. The Honest Company was sued in New York and California in 2016 over natural, naturally derived, and plant-based labels on products that included soap and shampoo, and paid $7.35 million to settle. Closer to home, Dr. Squatch has agreed to a $9 million class settlement over its "natural" labels while denying wrongdoing, with a final approval hearing set for March 2027.

What we say instead

A number with a published method behind it. We measure how much of the formula comes from natural sources under ISO 16128, the international standard for that count, and print it with the method named. The standard does not cover label claims, so the wording still has to hold up under FTC rules on its own. Then we seek COSMOS certification or EWG Verified status, so an outside certifier carries the meaning the adjective cannot carry by itself.

The money

The margins work if we price it like a brand, not like soap.

LinePer bar
Retail price$8.99
Wholesale price$4.50
Cost to make and packthe lowest it could be; the certifiable formula costs more~$1.50
Gross margin, directbefore shipping, fees, and ads~83%
Gross margin, wholesale~67%

Where $8.99 sits: a Baby Dove bar sells for about three dollars at Walmart, a Sebamed Baby bar for about five, and Mustela's bar for $12.50. Tubkins sits between the drugstore bar and the French pharmacy bar, and the character has to earn that gap.

These are modeled figures, not quotes. The $1.50 cost is only plausible at high volume, so the first real quotes come at 5,000, 25,000, and 100,000 units. One-time costs sit on top: custom dies, the full test set, and a production lead time of several months.

The bigger risk is retail. Slotting fees and trade spend can take a large share of revenue in mass retail, and size alone does not protect a baby brand there: Hello Bello, built mostly on diapers, had about $179 million in annual sales and still filed for Chapter 11 in 2023, in part because its biggest retailers would not accept its price increases. So the plan sells direct, on Amazon, and through Babylist first, where there is no slotting fee, and walks into Target only with proof in hand. Those channels still take a cut: Amazon charges fees, Babylist buys at wholesale or takes a commission, and direct orders pay for shipping and ads, so single bars ship in bundles or as the four-pack.

Rough capital to get to shelf: $500,000 to $1.5 million, modeled, not quoted.

How it gets built

Nine to fifteen months to something you can hold, with a stop sign at each gate.

  1. Protect the name and the look now

    Order the full trademark clearance search, confirm that Sunrise Soap's old Tubkins bath bombs are truly gone, and file the Section 1(b) application ($350) in an entity that can carry the business forward. Register the copyright in the character art. Get a patent lawyer's view on a design patent for the bar shape, because if this page counts as a public disclosure, the one-year U.S. grace period may already be running.

    Stop signRename if the clearance search turns up a live conflict.
  2. Prove the bar can be made months 1 to 3

    Ask Twincraft and Vanguard whether they can extrude and stamp a glutamate bar, whether it survives a wet tub, and what it costs compared with isethionate. Get samples.

    Stop signStop if neither glutamate nor a certified alternative holds up in a wet tub at a cost that leaves a brand margin.
  3. Test everything the label will say months 3 to 8

    Put the bar through the full test set: accelerated stability for color, odor, and cracking; a microbial risk check, since a syndet bar lacks the high pH that protects true soap; a repeat insult patch test; eye irritation testing, both an in vitro screen and a supervised human study, before we print tear-free; and a wet-tub test that tracks mush, wear, and how long the face stays readable. Put samples in the hands of 20 to 50 families and open a waitlist at tubkins.com.

    Stop signStop if the bar fails eye irritation testing, if the face is unreadable after a few weeks of baths, or if test parents still reach for the pump.
  4. Tool, pack, and register with FDA alongside testing

    Cut the dies and print the cartons only after the name is clear and a manufacturer has confirmed it can run the bar. The contract manufacturer registers its facility. We are the company named on the label, so we list each product, keep a safety file, put a U.S. contact for adverse events on the carton, and report serious adverse events to FDA within 15 business days. The small-business exemption from listing probably does not help us, because it excludes products that regularly contact the eye in normal use, and a tear-free baby shampoo bar invites that reading.

  5. Launch direct, Amazon, and Babylist months 9 to 15

    Babylist says more than 40 percent of first-time parents in the U.S. use its registry. A character bar is close to a perfect baby shower gift, which is a cheaper way to find customers than buying ads.

  6. Retail, then license the cast out year two

    Target and specialty baby once sales numbers show the bar moves off the shelf. Then, once the cast has a following, license Tubkins, Poppy, Sunny, and Minty onto towels, books, and bath toys.

← Back to the short version